How Climate-Driven Challenges Are Reshaping 1031 Exchange and Insurance Strategies

One of the largest concerns for investors is the rising cost and decreasing availability of property insurance in natural disaster-prone areas. High-risk locations like California and Florida, for example, which are often struck by hurricanes, floods, and the devastating recent wildfires, are becoming more challenging to insure. Even as these regions remain attractive for investors due to lifestyle appeal and economic opportunities, the potential long-term costs of risks must still be deeply considered.

First American Exchange Company President Julie Baird was interviewed by ConnectCRE about how climate-related issues continue to reshape how real estate investors pursue 1031 exchanges. The article covered a variety of subtopics; including the volume of natural disasters, how investors can leverage 1031 and 1033 exchange benefits, deadline extensions, and preparation tips.

In addition to guidance found in the article, below is further advice for 1031 exchange investors navigating natural disasters:

Considering Insurance Options During the Identification Period

Carefully and proactively assessing the geographical risks of potential investments during the 45-day identification period is key. Evaluating the long-term viability of a location in terms of climate resilience and property value trends is important, but availability and cost of property insurance should also be verified early on. An investor planning to use new financing together with 1031 exchange proceeds may find their identified properties are all in locations where insurers are unwilling to issue property insurance. This could effectively cause their exchange to fail if they cannot purchase any of the properties they identified without financing.

Know When and How You Are Affected

There are instances where investors even benefit from extended deadlines despite not being directly impacted by a natural disaster. For example, investors who by virtue of living in a disaster zone are automatically considered “affected taxpayers” yet haven’t had any challenges from the disaster, are automatically entitled to longer exchange periods. For some affected taxpayers who haven’t even begun an exchange yet, they may have extended exchange deadlines because of where they reside or their business is located, if they sell after a disaster occurs. While this is a narrow advantage, it is a silver lining and great opportunity for taxpayers who think they may be eligible for disaster extensions to discuss it with their tax advisor and a qualified intermediary.